CO129-260 - Governor Sir Robinson Acting Governor O-Brien - 1893 [9-12] — Page 81

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

80

of reforms which we regard gently required in the interests the College.

English.

which of

First, in the teaching of English, may be considered under three heads: Conversation, Composition and the Translation of Chinese into English.

English Conversation. The teaching of this above the eighth class dates from His Excellency's remarks on his first visit to the College; he has several times called attention to the importance of the subject, but there is no time set apart for it, nor has there been any systematic teaching of it. Consequently, great numbers of boys in the upper classes are unable to understand the simplest explanations given in English.

1. Conversation. In the teaching of Composition also, there is no systematic teaching up to the First Class. A story is read to the boys and they are expected to reproduce it without having had any training by means of such graduated lessons and exercises as are essential in learning a foreign language. Hence it is that a boy cannot construct grammatically a simple sentence.

2. Composition.

"Translation into English" consists in committing to memory a "crib" written out on the blackboard by the teacher. In fact, this subject is not taught. No intelligence is called forth, and the best rote-memory gains the highest marks in the examination. As a consequence, boys when they leave school are still incompetent to translate Chinese into English. We once suggested to you that the translation should be printed, so that time might be spared to teach the difference of construction between Chinese and English.

Edit History

2026-05-27 03:52:48 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
80 of reforms which we regard gently required in the interests the College. English. which of First, in the teaching of English, may be considered under three heads: Conversation, Composition and the Translation of Chinese into English. English Conversation. The teaching of this above the eighth class dates from His Excellency's remarks on his first visit to the College; he has several times called attention to the importance of the subject, but there is no time set apart for it, nor has there been any systematic teaching of it. Consequently, great numbers of boys in the upper classes are unable to understand the simplest explanations given in English. 1. Conversation. In the teaching of Composition also, there is no systematic teaching up to the First Class. A story is read to the boys and they are expected to reproduce it without having had any training by means of such graduated lessons and exercises as are essential in learning a foreign language. Hence it is that a boy cannot construct grammatically a simple sentence. 2. Composition. "Translation into English" consists in committing to memory a "crib" written out on the blackboard by the teacher. In fact, this subject is not taught. No intelligence is called forth, and the best rote-memory gains the highest marks in the examination. As a consequence, boys when they leave school are still incompetent to translate Chinese into English. We once suggested to you that the translation should be printed, so that time might be spared to teach the difference of construction between Chinese and English.
Baseline (Original)
80 of reforms which we regard. gently required in the interests the College. English. which of First, in the teaching of English, may be considered under three heads: Conversation, Composition and the Transcation of Chinese into English. English Conversation. The teaching of this above the eighth class dates from His Excellency's remarks on Juice then; his first visit to the have several times called attention. you College. to the importance of the subject, but. is there is no time set apart for it, nor has there been. any systematic teaching of it . Consequently, great incumbers of boys in the upper classes are unable to understand the simplest explanations given in English. 1. Conversus. Translation In the teaching of Composition 2. Composi estern up to the First also, there is no Class. Chinese to English. C Class. A story is read to the boys and this they without meaus expected to reproduce, are having had any training by of such graduated lessons and exercises as are essential in a learning foreign language. Hence it is that a boy cannot construct, first class & gram. matically a simple sentence. "Franslation into English - consists in committing to memory a "crib" written out on the blackboard. the teacher. In fact, this subject is not taught. No by intelligence is called forth, and the best rote - memory gaires the highest marks in the exam. innation. As a consequence boys, when that the trans. they leave school are still incompe. tent to translate Chinese into English. We once suggested to you casion should be printed, so that time might be spared to teach the difference of construction between Chinese and English
2026-05-27 03:52:48 · Baseline
View content

80

of reforms which we

regard.

gently required in the interests

the College.

English.

which

of

First, in the teaching of English,

may

be considered under three heads: Conversation, Composition and the Transcation of Chinese into English.

English Conversation. The

teaching of this above the eighth class

dates from His Excellency's remarks on

Juice then; his first visit to the

have several times called attention.

you

College.

to the importance of the subject, but.

is

there is no time set apart for it, nor has there been.

any systematic teaching

of it . Consequently, great incumbers of boys in the upper classes are unable to understand the simplest explanations given in English.

1. Conversus. Translation

In the teaching of Composition 2. Composi estern up to the First

also, there is no

Class.

Chinese to

English.

C

Class. A story is read to the boys and

this they

without

meaus

expected to reproduce,

are

having

had

any training by

of such graduated lessons and

exercises as are essential in

a

learning

foreign language. Hence it is that a

boy

cannot construct,

first class

& gram. matically a simple sentence.

"Franslation into English -

consists in committing to memory a

"crib" written out on the blackboard. the teacher. In fact, this subject is not taught. No

by

intelligence

is called

forth, and the best rote - memory

gaires the highest marks in the exam. innation. As a consequence boys,

when

that the trans.

they leave school are still incompe. tent to translate Chinese into English. We once

suggested to you casion should be printed, so that time might be spared to teach the difference of construction between Chinese and

English

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.